Publisher Summary
Salem Reporter, a local news site in Oregon, runs a metered paywall on WordPress: one free article, an email on the second, the paid offer on the third.
In one 30-day window, that brought in 640 registered readers and 71 paid subscribers.
The plan is three steps: ask for an email, send the newsletter, then ask for money when readers know what they’d be paying for.
Most of your readers open one article and leave. Lock everything and they leave sooner. Lock nothing and you never learn who they were.
A metered paywall for WordPress sits between the two. It’s a plugin that counts the articles each reader opens, then asks them to register or pay after a number you set.
The worry is what you might lose. Will search traffic drop? Will readers get annoyed and go? We know the hesitation. An email for more reading is a fair trade.
Salem Reporter was collecting emails with newsletter signup forms. Then they switched paywall systems and set the meter at one free article a month. Their plan has three steps:
- Ask for an email.
- Send the newsletter.
- Ask for money when readers know what they’d be paying for.
Over 600 news and magazine publishers run their subscriptions on Leaky Paywall, the WordPress paywall we build. This is the plan we give them, with the meter settings that go with each step.
What is a metered paywall?
A metered paywall gives each reader a set number of free articles, then asks them to register or pay.
A hard paywall locks every article. A metered paywall leaks a few on purpose, so search engines and new readers still get in. (That’s where the name Leaky Paywall comes from.)
Salem Reporter’s meter has two stops. The second article asks for a free account with an email, which is a registration wall. The third shows the paid offer.
Learn more: soft paywall vs hard paywall.
Will a metered paywall hurt my search traffic?
Not if search engines can still read your articles.
Leaky Paywall has a setting called Search Engine Bot Bypass. It lets search engines read restricted articles, so they keep getting indexed. The full method is in SEO strategy for paywalled content.
Greenpointers, a Brooklyn neighborhood news site, set their meter at three free articles. Six weeks later traffic was up 40% month over month, and they’d added over 1,000 emails. The newsletter is the reason: every send brings registered readers back to your site.
What happens to the subscribers I already have?
You keep them.
Leaky Paywall is a WordPress plugin, so your subscribers are WordPress users in your own database, and payments run through your own Stripe account.
If you’re switching from another paywall, the Pro and Enterprise plans include moving your existing subscribers over. Salem Reporter made that switch a few months before the 30 days counted here.
We take nothing on subscribers you had before you joined us.
How many free articles should a metered paywall allow?
One. Ask for an email on the second article.
The average reader views 1.7 articles per website visit. With one free article, roughly 70% of your readers see the wall. With three, it’s roughly 30%. At four or five, the wall barely shows.
Check your own number first. It’s pages per visit in your analytics.
What’s a good signup rate? In 2026, across 12 publishers running the same registration wall after one free article, 3.2 to 6.7% of the readers who saw it signed up. That’s 32 to 67 emails from every 1,000 readers who see the wall. A newsletter popup gets about 9.
Tea Journey, a niche magazine, is at 3.6%. News sites sit toward the low end of that range and niche titles toward the high end.
If one free article feels too tight for day one, start at three and tighten from there. Greenpointers got their 1,000 emails at three.
The wall settings that move the numbers are in our guide to the registration wall.
How do you set up a metered paywall in WordPress?
The meter and the registration wall are in the free Leaky Paywall plugin.
- Install the plugin. In WordPress, go to Plugins > Add Plugin, search for Leaky Paywall, then install and activate it. The setup wizard opens by itself. (Download Leaky Paywall Free)
- Let the wizard create your pages. There are four: login, subscribe, register and profile. If you run a caching plugin, exclude those four pages from the cache.
- Keep the defaults. One free article, and an email only. The meter is under Leaky Paywall > Settings > Restrictions if you want to change it.
- Write your wall. Say what the reader gets, and say it’s free. The copy and colors are under Leaky Paywall > Settings > General > List Builder. (List Builder is the name of the registration wall in the settings.)
- Test it as a reader. Open an article in a private window, then a second one. Register, and check the welcome email arrives.
How often should I send the newsletter?
Weekly is the floor.
At Salem Reporter, the free registration comes with the newsletter. Every new registered reader starts hearing from them.
Mexico News Daily sends two newsletters a day and runs no ads. They went from 500,000 to 2 million monthly visitors in about two years.
On the free plugin, you export your registered readers to Mailchimp, Kit or ActiveCampaign. Paid plans sync them automatically.
When should the meter show the paid offer?
After readers have registered and heard from you.
Why? A cold reader sees a price before they know you. A registered reader gets your newsletter first, comes back a few times, and sees the offer once the habit is there.
Piano’s benchmark study put a cold paywall at 0.22% of website visitors, against 9.88% for registered readers.
Salem Reporter shows the paid offer on the third article, and over 20% of their registered readers go on to pay. At Small Boats, nearly 3 in 10 registered readers became paid subscribers.
Should every reader get the same meter?
For most publishers, yes: one free article, then ask for an email. A smaller site doesn’t need more than that.
The exception is a larger publisher with a lot of returning readers. A fixed meter gives a daily reader and a first-time reader the same allowance. Set it loose and your most loyal readers never see an offer. Set it tight and new readers meet the wall before they know you. WAN-IFRA found that under a fixed meter, 40 to 60% of readers on premium articles never see the paywall.
On paid plans, Leaky Paywall’s Dynamic Paywall sets the meter by how often each reader comes back:
- New reader: 4 free articles. Loose on purpose, so the habit can form.
- Casual reader: 3 free articles.
- Regular reader: 2 free articles.
- Loyal reader: 0 free articles. They already know what they’d be paying for.
It works for anonymous readers and for known, logged-in ones, and scores each on three things: how recently they visited, how often, and how much they read.
A first-time reader has no history to score. For them the meter can go by the visit: a reader who arrives from an ad, or who opens a premium article, gets fewer free articles. That setting is called Intent Boost.
Why it works: when the New York Times tightened its paywall, page views fell 9.9% and subscriptions rose 31% (Aral and Dhillon, Management Science).
Action step: if you turn it on, start with those defaults and a 30-day scoring window. Change one number at a time, and watch signups and page views together. You control the dial.
Can I meter by category, or by what a reader already pays for?
Yes. The meter follows your content and your subscription levels.
- Standard articles: on the meter. Readers and search engines get the free ones.
- Premium categories: locked to paid levels. Every article you publish in that WordPress category is restricted.
The free plugin restricts by category, tag or article, with hooks and filters if your developer wants more. A local news site can leave the events calendar open, meter the daily news, and lock the investigations and the archive.
Every logged-in reader is a WordPress user, so the paywall knows what they already have. A free registered reader sees the paid offer. A monthly subscriber on a premium article sees the upgrade. On an article only paid levels can read, the wall shows the upgrade, since a free signup wouldn’t open it.
Any WordPress plugin can be a subscriber benefit. One publisher gives paid subscribers unlimited classifieds.
Can readers or AI bots get around a metered paywall?
Not on the articles you lock to paid levels.
Leaky Paywall’s Restriction Method setting (Leaky Paywall > Settings > Restrictions) has three options: Automatic, JavaScript and Server. New installs are set to Automatic. On Automatic, paid-only articles are locked on your server, so the full text never reaches the page source. That’s total protection from AI bots for those articles: there’s nothing on the page to take. In your RSS feed they show the excerpt and a link.
Metered articles are checked in the browser, so the meter keeps working with page caching. Their text is on the page for a reader who still has free articles left, and a bot can read it there. Lock on the server anything you don’t want a bot to have.
You will need to decide how far to let Google in, since the crawler that sends you search traffic also feeds AI Overviews. Some publishers want to be cited there. Should publishers block AI bots?
Private windows are the other way round. Most people use incognito mode to get around paywalls, and a cookie-based meter resets every time.
The IP Blocker on paid plans defends against incognito mode: it counts views at the network level, so switching browsers or opening a private window doesn’t reset the meter.
Why use a WordPress plugin and not a hosted paywall?
Two reasons: your readers’ accounts stay in WordPress, and the restrictions are native, so you get more ways to lock content.
A hosted paywall runs as a script on top of your site and keeps reader accounts on the vendor’s servers. With a plugin, readers log in with the WordPress login, payments go to your own Stripe account, and the meter rules live in your own settings.
Because Leaky Paywall runs inside WordPress, it can hard lock an article, meter it, or change the message each reader sees, and you set those rules by category or tag. Your developer can go further with hooks and filters.
Mexico News Daily moved off a hosted subscription system and was live on Leaky Paywall in under 60 days. Their email list tripled, and 9% of their free registered readers went on to pay.
Does a metered paywall work with page caching?
Yes, on the Automatic setting.
Paid-only articles are locked on the server and metered articles are checked in the browser, so a cached page still counts the view. Exclude the login, subscribe, register and profile pages from your cache.
Is there a free metered paywall plugin for WordPress?
Yes. Leaky Paywall Free includes the meter, the registration wall, Stripe, and restriction by category, tag or article.
You can sell subscriptions on it too. Set up as many levels as you need, such as an annual plan, each taken as a one-time payment. Building your email list is free. Once you start charging, we take 10% of payments from new paid subscribers, and nothing on the ones you already had. Paid plans add recurring billing, the Dynamic Paywall, trials and coupons, automatic sync to your email tool, and setup help on Zoom. Here’s what each plan costs: Leaky Paywall pricing.
A few months after switching, Salem Reporter counted one 30-day window: 640 new registered readers and 71 new paid subscribers. That’s more than two paid subscribers a day.
Install the free plugin and keep the defaults. Or book 30 minutes with us, and we’ll tell you whether we’re the right fit.
Pete
