Publisher Summary
Twelve WordPress publishers run the same Leaky Paywall registration wall after one free article.
The registration wall signs up 3.2 to 6.7% of the readers who see it. A newsletter popup signs up about 0.9%. That’s two to seven times the email signups, from traffic you already have.
The settings that matter most: one free article, an email-only first screen, and wall copy that says what the reader gets.
A registration wall asks a reader to create a free account with an email address to keep reading. A paywall asks for payment. (You’ll also see a registration wall called a regwall.) It’s one kind of gated content.
The full numbers are in the Publisher’s AI Survival Guide. If you’re still weighing it up, start with why a newsletter popup is the wrong tool and 5 things a registration wall does that a popup can’t.
Below are the questions publishers ask us on calls before they turn on a registration wall for WordPress, and what we tell them.
Should I offer free registration or charge right away?
Start with free registration.
Salem Reporter gives readers one free article, shows a registration wall on the second and a paywall on the third. Over 20% of their registered readers go on to pay. At Small Boats, nearly 3 in 10 registered readers became paid subscribers.
Why? A registered reader has traded an email, opened your newsletter and come back a few times. By the time they see a price, they know what they’d be paying for. Piano’s benchmark study put a cold paywall at 0.22% of visitors, against 9.88% for registered readers.
One publisher we work with is running free registration only for the first three to six months. They build the list and learn who their readers are. Payments come after.
Looking to grow your publication?
Sign up for expert advice straight to your inbox.Will a registration wall hurt my traffic or SEO?
Greenpointers is a Brooklyn neighborhood news site. Six weeks after they put a registration wall on their articles, traffic was up 40% month over month. They’d also added over 1,000 emails.
The newsletter is the reason. Every send brings registered readers back to your site.
Your search traffic stays too. You can let search engines through the wall so your articles keep getting indexed (more on bots below).
How many free articles should readers get before they register?
One. The wall goes up on the second article.
The average reader views 1.7 articles per website visit. With one free article, roughly 70% of your visitors see the wall. With three free articles, it’s roughly 30%. At four or five, the wall barely shows.
Check your own number first. It’s pages per visit in your analytics.
If one free article feels too tight for day one, start at three and tighten from there. Greenpointers got those 1,000 emails at three free articles.
What should the registration form ask for?
An email address. That’s the whole first screen.
The Fisherman switched to an email-only registration wall, and registrations went up 10x in two weeks.
A B2B publisher we’re working with had a registration flow that ran seven screens: business details, role, membership levels, interests, newsletters, a thank you. Their new version is two.
The second screen is where a new reader picks a password, and where you can add your own questions. Keep it to one, maybe two. Every field you add costs you signups.
A marketing lead said it to us on a call: “I’m already annoyed that I can’t read without putting my information in, then you’re asking your questions on top of that.”
Pick the question that pays your reader back. That B2B publisher asks for a zip code, because it sets the local data a reader sees across the site. Another publisher asks for job role and sends it to HubSpot.
Ask for the rest later. Skip first and last name at the wall. Extra fields live on the reader’s My Account page, and the Reader Bar can prompt a logged-in reader to fill them in.
The same form is your login. A reader who already has an account types an email and gets a password prompt. A new reader gets the signup screen.
What should the wall say?
Say what the reader gets, and say it’s free.
The Olive Press changed one word on their wall, and registrations came in 20% faster.
Here are two registration wall examples, one weak and one stronger.
Instead of: “Register to continue reading.” with a “Submit” button.
Try: “Get unlimited access and the top stories in your inbox every Friday. Free.” with a “Keep reading free” button.
List Builder is the registration wall in the free Leaky Paywall plugin. In its settings you edit the heading, the subheading, the terms line and the colors. Fonts come from your WordPress theme. Your designer can go further with CSS.
How do we keep junk signups out?
Start with the gates open. Tighten only if you see a problem.
- Turn off the direct registration link. Readers can then only sign up through the wall on an article. That stops most bot signups.
- Let the email check run. It flags junk addresses before they register. It isn’t bulletproof, but it works pretty well.
- Add the six-digit code only if you need it. New readers confirm their email before the account is created. It costs you real signups, so save it for when junk is getting through.
Can AI bots read around the wall?
Not if the wall runs on your server.
Leaky Paywall can restrict an article two ways. The JavaScript option hides the article in the browser, but the text is still in the page source. The PHP option removes the text before the page is sent, so there’s nothing there for a bot to read.
You can still let search engines through. You will need to decide how far to let Google in: its search crawler and its AI features are hard to separate, so the bot that sends you SEO traffic can also feed AI Overviews. This decision gets easier as your email list grows. We walk through it in Should publishers block AI bots?
For your best work, hard-lock a category. Every article you publish in that WordPress category is restricted on the server. One B2B publisher we work with keeps news free with registration and puts premium analysis and data behind a hard wall for paying members.
Can we pre-check the newsletter box?
If you have readers in the EU or Canada, leave the box unchecked and let the reader tick it. Kate on our team works from Spain, and the rules there are strict.
For readers in the US you have more room. Either way, say on the wall what lands in their inbox and how often. If you’re unsure, ask your lawyer.
Where do the emails go, and what do I do with them?
New registrations go to wherever you send email: Mailchimp, Kit, ActiveCampaign, HubSpot, Salesforce. On the free plugin you export them. Paid plans sync automatically, and we map your extra fields into your CRM during setup.
Then send the newsletter. Weekly is the floor.
On Leaky Paywall Pro, Subscriber Insights tracks every logged-in reader. Who keeps hitting your upgrade message? Which link or campaign did they register from? What do they read, by category? Who hasn’t been back in 30 or 60 days?
Email the readers who keep hitting the upgrade message. Write to the ones going quiet.
How to set up a registration wall in WordPress this week
- Open your analytics and find your pages per visit.
- Install Leaky Paywall Free and turn on the List Builder registration wall. It’s free for building your email list. If you turn on paid subscriptions later, we take 10% of payments from new paid subscribers.
- Set the meter to one free article (three if you want a softer start) and ask for an email only.
- Count your new registrations after two weeks.
Want a second opinion on where to set your wall? Book 30 minutes with me and Kate. On paid plans, Kate sets the wall up with you on Zoom.
Pete
